All the games you need

Guides · Rare Bird

Rare Bird: how to find the rarer answers

Rare Bird asks for one answer to each of seven prompts and pays more the fewer people would think of it. The first right answer you type is the one that counts, so the whole game is in what you type first.

Play Rare Bird

The rules, in one breath

Seven prompts a day, 25 seconds each: name one thing that fits. Every answer the game knows is written down beforehand in its book, in a tier that says how many people would think of it, and a right answer scores what its tier is worth:

Your first right answer is the one that counts

The moment you type something that is in the book, the prompt is over and that answer is yours, pigeon or rare bird. You cannot trade it in for a better one. So the order you try things in is the whole game: start with the rarest answer you are sure is real, and fall back towards the safe ones only as the clock runs down.

A miss is free, apart from the seconds it takes. “Not in the book” leaves what you typed in the box, ready to mend, and typing the same miss again is not counted twice. So it costs nothing to try an owl first and a kingfisher next, as long as you leave yourself time for a robin.

Run out of time and the prompt scores nothing, so keep a safe answer ready for the last few seconds. The prompt is on the board for three seconds before its clock starts: the box is ready to type in, though nothing can be sent until the clock begins, so use those seconds to think. Between prompts nothing runs at all, since the next prompt only comes up when you press Next prompt, and an answer sent at the very last moment still counts.

Why going deeper pays

The book is fullest where the points are good. A typical prompt has three or four pigeons, about seven robins, a dozen kingfishers and thirty or more owls, with exactly one rare bird at the top. So a real, specific answer that takes a little knowing is very likely to be in it somewhere above the pigeons, and an owl is worth 8.5 pigeons.

Three stars needs 351 or more out of 700, an average of just over 50 a prompt. A kingfisher on every prompt is enough, and so is a mix of owls and robins. Seven robins come to 210, which is two stars, and seven pigeons to 70.

The tiers are an editor’s judgement of how many people would give each answer, not a survey. What players type is collected, with nothing that says who typed it, so that the judgement can be checked and the book put right.

How to think of a rarer answer

Say the prompt were “Name a shade of green”. That is an invented prompt, with an invented book, to show the ways down from the pigeons: lime and olive are what nearly everyone says, emerald and mint come soon after, sage and jade take a little more, and viridian or celadon fewer people again. The ways to get there work on any prompt:

Another name is not a rarer answer

Saying a common thing by an unusual name does not make it rare. Every answer in the book carries its other names with it, in the same tier, so a pigeon called by its old or foreign name is still a pigeon, if the book knows the name at all. The points are for thinking of a different thing, not for a different way of saying the same one.

The decoy

The decoy is worth 15: the answer that feels clever to everybody, which half the room writes down when they try to be unusual. Most prompts have no decoy at all and a few have one or two, so it is not a trap to fear on every prompt, but it is a reason to distrust the first clever answer that comes to you.

In the invented example, chartreuse might be the decoy: it is the word people reach for when they want to sound knowing about green. If an unusual answer arrives at once, it has probably arrived for others too. Go one step past it to something more particular, and keep the decoy as a fallback, since it still beats a pigeon.

Typing it so it counts

The game knows what you meant through most slips. Capitals, accents and punctuation do not matter, nor a leading “the” or “a”, nor “Sir” or “Dame” before a name. Plurals are fine, including ones in -ES and -VES, and so is a missing or extra space. St and Saint are the same, and so are Mt and Mount. A word of the prompt typed along with the answer does no harm, and you can leave off a last word that only repeats what the prompt asks for.

One slipped letter is forgiven in an answer of six letters or more, and two in one of twelve or more, but never in the first letter, and never in a number, a Roman numeral or an initial, because those say which of two things you mean. An answer of five letters or fewer has to be spelt right.

Nearly right is asked about. If what you typed sounds like an answer, or has its words in another form or order, the board asks “Did you mean …?” with the answer’s name. Press Yes, or Enter on what is still in the box, and it scores. Type anything else and it counts as a miss, and your new answer is looked up instead. The question names the answer but not its tier, so if you suspect a pigeon and have the time, you may prefer to type something rarer.

Stars, points and the notebook

A walk is scored out of 700: three stars from 351, two from 201, and one for anything above nothing. In the city’s points, half marks are worth a solve, so a walk of 350 is worth 300, 500 or 800 by the day, and a perfect walk twice that. There is no speed bonus, since the clock is the same for everyone, and there are no hints. A walk is also named by its total: from 450, “A rare bird yourself”; from 351, “Field expert”; from 251, “Keen eye”; from 151, “Garden regular”; below that, “Pigeon fancier”.

The seven prompts are a mix of geography, nature, food, the arts, sport and everyday things, and none comes round again until the whole book has been walked. When the walk is over, the notebook lists them: tap one to see every answer in its book, tier by tier. It is the quickest way to learn how deep each kind of prompt goes.

Questions

How is Rare Bird scored?

By how rare each answer is. A right answer scores its tier: 10 for a pigeon, 15 for a decoy, 30 for a robin, 60 for a kingfisher, 85 for an owl and 100 for the rare bird, out of 700 for the walk.

What is the decoy in Rare Bird?

An answer that feels clever but that half the room thinks of too, worth 15. Most prompts have none; when an unusual answer comes to you at once, try one step past it first.

Does a wrong answer cost anything in Rare Bird?

Only time, so type another straight away. The one thing that scores nothing is running out the 25-second clock.

Can I change my answer once it is accepted?

No. The first answer you type that is in the book ends the prompt, so type your rarest sure answer first and the safe one last.

What if my right answer is not in the book?

It is turned down as not in the book, so type another. What players type is kept, with nothing that says who typed it, so that missing answers can be added.

How do I get three stars in Rare Bird?

Score 351 or more out of 700: about a kingfisher on every prompt, or owls on some of them.

Play Rare BirdEvery guide